1Division of Metabolism, Cruces University Hospital and BioCruces Health Research Institute, Plaza de Cruces s/n, 48903, Barakaldo, Spain. GCV-CIBER de Enfermedades Raras (CIBERER), Instituto de Salud Carlos III, Spain
2Unit of Diagnosis and Treatment of Congenital Metabolic Diseases, Department of Pediatrics, Hospital Clínico Universitario de Santiago de Compostela, CIBERER, Health Research Institute of Santiago de Compostela (IDIS), A Choupana, s/n, 15706 Santiago de Compostela, A Coruña, Spain
Citation: Echevarría LA, Llarena M, et al. Phenylketonuria Treatment’s Impact on Physical Growth: A Spanish Retrospective Longitudinal Study. J Rare Dis Diagn Ther. 2015, 1:2. doi:10.21767/2380-7245.100014
Copyright: © 2015 Echevarría LA, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Background: Phenylketonuria treatment based on phenylalanine-restricted diet has proven to be effective in preventing the development of long-term neurological damage. However, such diets have occasionally been reported to hinder normal development. Furthermore, to improve outcomes in these patients therapy based on administration of the cofactor BH4 has emerged. However, little is known about how BH4 treatment affects physical development. Methods and Findings: Firstly, in order to evaluate the impact of the phenylketonuria diet on anthropometric characteristics we conducted a retrospective longitudinal study. Anthropometric characteristics and nutrition were evaluated from birth to adulthood in a cohort of phenylketonuria and mild-hyperphenylalaninemia patients, who were exclusively on protein-restricted diets, and were compared to the Spanish reference population. Patients with phenylketonuria showed growth impairment in early stages, with higher phenylalanine intakes being associated with improved developmental outcomes over this period. Secondly, we conducted a retrospective longitudinal study in a cohort of patients with phenylketonuria on BH4 treatment and compared their developmental outcomes with those of a group of patients on a phenylalanine-restricted diet, in order to determine whether BH4 treatment was associated with an improvement in growth development. No improvement was observed in the anthropometric variables in the BH4-treated group, from prior to initiating treatment to when they had taken the drug for 2 or 5 years. In addition, growth impairment was also observed in patients on lowphenylalanine diets. In fact, individuals on long-term BH4 treatment seemed to achieve similar developmental outcomes to those on more restricted diets. Conclusions: Our results suggest that prescribing very stringent diets in early stages might predispose these patients to later growth retardation, with growth outcomes in adulthood being well below the 50th percentile for healthy subjects. In conclusion, our study identified growth impairment in patients with phenylketonuria on BH4 treatment, despite the fact that their natural protein intake increased.
Phenylketonuria; Phe-restricted diet; tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4); physical outcomes; growth
BH4: (6R)-L-erythro-5,6,7,8-tetrahydrobiopterin; BMI: Body mass index; GR: Growth rate; HPA: Hyperphenylalaninemia; PAH: Phenylalanine 4-hydroxylase; Phe: Phenylalanine; PKU: Phenylketonuria; RDA: Recommended dietary allowance; WHO: World Health Organisation
Phenylketonuria (PKU; OMIM 261600) is an autosomal recessive inborn error of metabolism affecting the phenylalanine (Phe) metabolic pathway, which converts Phe to tyrosine via phenylalanine 4-hydroxylase (PAH; EC 220.127.116.11) and its cofactor (6R)-L-erythro-5,6,7,8-tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4). Depending on the plasma Phe levels at the time of diagnosis and the Phe tolerance, patients are classified into four phenotypic categories: mild-hyperphenylalaninemia (HPA), which does not require further treatment; mild-PKU; moderate-PKU and classic-PKU. If untreated, PKU can result in impaired cognitive development as a consequence of the neurotoxic effect of Phe accumulation .
PKU treatment consists of strict vegetarian diets, with very low Phe intake and supplemented with Phe-free protein substitutes and specially-manufactured low-protein foods. This Pherestricted diet aims to maintain blood Phe levels below preestablished “safe” thresholds; and has proven to be effective in preventing the development of long-term neurological damage caused by Phe accumulation [2,3]. However, such diets have occasionally been reported to hinder normal development, since some individuals presented growth retardation and malnutrition [4-6]. Several studies have attempted to establish a connection between a reduction in natural protein intake and growth retardation, but their findings have been inconsistent. Therefore, we firstly conducted a retrospective longitudinal study, in order to evaluate the impact of PKU protein-restricted diet on anthropometric characteristics. The aim was to further explore the hypothesis of higher natural protein intake being associated with attaining improved physical outcomes in patients with PKU. In this study, anthropometric characteristics and nutrition were evaluated from birth to adulthood in a cohort of patients with PKU and mild-HPA, who were exclusively on protein-restricted diets; and were compared to the Spanish reference population .
Treating patients with PKU represents a huge nutritional challenge. In the last decades, several alternative approaches for the treatment of PKU have emerged in an attempt to improve outcomes in these patients; for example, large neutral amino acid supplementation, BH4 therapy and novel protein sources (such as glycomacropeptide) . These strategies focuses on maintaining blood Phe levels within pre-established “safe” thresholds, ameliorating secondary complications as a result of daily nutrient intake below recommended dietary allowances (RDAs) , as well as increasing patients’ dietary adherence. PAH-deficient patients positively responding to BH4 treatment were observed for the first time in 1999 by Kure et al. . Therapy based on this cofactor has opened up new treatment possibilities for a significant proportion of these patients, namely those responding to a BH4 loading test. So far, clinical data on BH4 treatment’s benefits have highlighted a remarkable increase in Phe tolerance, a reduction in the fluctuation of blood Phe levels and an improvement in nutritional status and quality of life [9,11-13]. In addition, BH4 treatment allows patients with PKU to partially or totally liberalise their Phe-restricted diet, reducing their need to be supplemented with protein substitutes and enabling them to increase their intake of natural proteins. However, so far there is little clinical evidence regarding the impact of BH4 treatment on PKU patient physical growth and the results from the few published studies have been inconclusive [14,15]. Therefore, we secondly conducted a retrospective longitudinal study of anthropometric characteristics in a cohort of patients with PKU on BH4 treatment and compared their developmental outcomes with those of a group of patients on a Phe-restricted diet, in order to determine whether BH4 treatment was associated with an improvement in growth development. We also assessed nutritional status, in order to further investigate the association of higher natural protein intake with improved developmental outcomes .
We conducted a retrospective, longitudinal, multicentre study of PAH-deficient patients, who were regularly treated and monitored at several Spanish hospitals. Patients were classified into one of the four phenotypic categories according to their blood Phe levels, which were measured at diagnosis: classic PKU (Phe > 1200 mol/L), moderate PKU (Phe: 600-1200 mol/L), mild PKU (Phe: 360-600 mol/L) and mild-HPA (Phe < 360 mol/L). The inclusion criteria for the study were: (1) early diagnosis of PKU or mild-HPA; (2) in the case of patients on a PKU diet, exclusive and continuous treatment with Phe-restricted diet, supplemented with Phe-free substitutes and specially manufactured lowprotein foods, the diet being initiated within days or weeks of birth; (3) absence of any other diseases known to affect physical development; (4) Caucasian race; and (5) regular attendance to their scheduled clinical check-ups. A total of 505 PAH-deficient patients were included in this study: 279 were diagnosed with PKU (130 males, 149 females), and 226 with mild-HPA (106 males, 120 females). The PKU group consisted of 43 patients with mild PKU, 78 with moderate PKU and 158 with classic PKU. Their ages ranged from 1 to 36 years.
Patients with PKU below 17 years of age were included in a second retrospective longitudinal study from thirteen hospitals in Spain. The study included patients with classic, moderate and mild PKU. They were divided into two groups according to their treatment: (1) BH4 treatment (until 2009 as [6R]-L-erythro-5,6,7,8- tetrahydrobiopterin [Schircks Laboratories, Jona, Switzerland], and thereafter sapropterin dihydrochloride [KUVAN®, Merck, Madrid, Spain]), and (2) exclusively Phe-restricted diet. The inclusion criteria for this study were: (1) early diagnosis, confirmed by mutation analysis of PAH gene; (2) in the case of patients on a PKU diet, early and continuous treatment with Phe-restricted diet, supplemented with Phe-free substitutes and specially manufactured low-protein foods; (3) in the case of BH4 patients, responsiveness to BH4 treatment (a defect in the BH4 pathways being ruled out by analysing urinary pterin levels); (4) absence of any other diseases known to affect physical development; (5) Caucasian race and (6) regular attendance to their scheduled clinical check-ups. Weight and height were collected over a period of two or five years, every 6 months, from the date when BH4 treatment was initiated. The same timetable was used in the dietonly group, in order to compare the evolution of anthropometrics and nutrition between both populations. Height, weight, BMI and GR measurements were converted into Z-scores by subtracting the expected mean measurement for the corresponding age and gender and dividing by its standard deviation. We used the 2008 Spanish Growth Studies as the source of data for the reference population [17,18].
Blood Phe concentrations were measured at diagnosis and every 6 months thereafter, in order to evaluate the effectiveness of the prescribed diet for each patient and monitor their adherence to the treatment. According to the Spanish protocol for treating and monitoring patients with PKU [19,20], blood Phe levels should remain below cut-offs established for each age group: < 360 μmol/L, for individuals < 6 years of age; < 480 μmol/L for those from 6 to ≤ 10 years of age, and < 600 μmol/L for those > 10 years of age.
With regard to nutrition, dietary intervention was started at diagnosis. Patients were on Phe-restricted diets, supplemented with Phe-free amino acid mixtures and specially-manufactured low-protein foods. Specifically, they had a restricted intake of protein-rich foods (such as meat, fish, eggs, milk and dairy products, and legumes) as well as foods with moderate protein content (such as cereals). The daily amount of natural protein prescribed for each individual was modified according to their age and the most recent blood Phe values. The recommended daily intake of protein substitutes was also based on patients’ age and they were advised to divide it into at least four daily doses. Dietary parameters (such as intakes of natural protein, protein contained in amino acid mixtures, total protein and Phe) were calculated by an experienced dietician from the 3-day food records completed by parents/legal guardians. In the present study, nutritional data were analysed every 6 months from birth to 18 years of age for 98 out of the 279 patients with PKU; but not in the case of patients with mild-HPA due to incomplete records.
Generally, BH4 responsiveness is evaluated using a BH4 loading test. The BH4 loading test used in this study was based on recommendations in the Spanish protocol for treating and monitoring patients with PKU [7,16,19,20]. Briefly, participants were loaded with Phe before BH4 administration. In general, an individual was considered to be a primary responder to BH4 treatment when blood Phe levels fell by at least 30 % within 8 h after BH4 administration. Patients who showed a reduction in blood Phe levels of at least 30 % within 12 h after BH4 administration were classified as late responders. From 2005 onwards, BH4 responsiveness was evaluated based upon the 50 % criterion at Virgen del Rocío University Hospital (for a full description of the protocol, see reference ). This BH4 loading test was designed as a two-stage protocol. In the first stage (the 24-h test), participants were loaded with Phe before BH4 administration. With this initial stage of the protocol, an individual was considered BH4 responsive when blood Phe levels fell by at least 50 % within 24 h after BH4 administration. PKU patients who did not meet the aforementioned criterion for responsiveness underwent the therapeutic test. In this second stage of the protocol, patients were administered a BH4 dose of 20 mg/kg per day for one week together with a daily intake of protein, set on a case-by-case basis in line with age- and genderspecific RDAs. The results of the therapeutic test were considered to be positive when Phe levels remained below an established threshold (< 360 μmol/L, for individuals < 6 years of age; < 480 μmol/L for those from 6 to ≤ 10 years of age, and < 600 μmol/L for those > 10 years of age). Patients who met this criterion were classed as late responders.
Statistical analysis was performed with the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences, SPSS® 20.0 for Windows (IBM, Chicago, IL, USA). The threshold for statistically significant differences was set at p < 0.05. Initially, all data were analysed using the Kolmogorov–Smirnov test, to assess whether the data were normally distributed. Descriptive statistics are presented as mean ± standard deviation (SD) for those variables which did satisfy the normality assumption. For non-parametric variables, descriptive statistics are presented as median and interquartile range. Differences between groups were assessed by using Student's t-test for paired data. Pearson correlation coefficients (r) were calculated to assess bivariate correlations for parametric variables.
Anthropometric characteristics and nutrition in a Spanish cohort of PAH-deficit patients exclusively treated with protein- restricted diets
Clinical, biochemical and nutritional data were collected for the first 18 years of life in patients with PKU and for the first 12 years of life in patients with mild-HPA. The anthropometric characteristics which were assessed in our study were: height, weight, body mass index (BMI) and growth rate (GR), which were converted into Z-scores by subtracting the expected mean measurement for the corresponding age and gender and dividing by its standard deviation. BMI was calculated using the formula BMI = weight (kg)/ height2 (m2). GR was calculated from two height measurements, which were taken approximately 1 year apart. We used the 2008 Spanish Growth Studies as the source of data for the reference population [17,18]. The statistical analysis indicated that mean Z-score for weight gradually decreased during the first 2 years of life to a nadir of -0.59 ± 0.95 and -0.51 ± 0.99 in male and female patients with PKU, respectively. From 2 to 3.5 years of age, it gradually increased and remained almost steady until 16.5 years of age (mean Z-scores for weight close to 0 and -0.2, in the male and female group, respectively). In adulthood, mean Z-score for weight in the male group fell well below the 50th percentile for healthy subjects (-0.51 ± 0.82), and it rose above this threshold in the female group (0.34 ± 1.13). In contrast, mean Z-score for weight in patients with mild-HPA remained close to 0 over the observation period. With regard to height Z-scores in the PKU group, they behaved similarly to weight Z-scores. They fell well below 0 during the first 2 years of life (mean Z-scores for height: -0.87 ± 1.14 and -0.68 ± 1.16 in the males and female group, respectively), and then recovered slightly towards 0. From 16.5 to 18 years, mean Z-score for height in the male group dropped to a final value of -0.89 ± 1.03. In the female group, mean Z-scores for height decreased steadily from 12 years of age to adulthood (final value -0.88 ± 0.81). On the other hand, mean Z-scores for height in male patients with mild-HPA were above the 50th percentile for the healthy population, but fell to -0.49 ± 1.06 at 12 years of age; while in the female group, it fell to a nadir of -0.59 ± 1.27 at 7.5 years of age, and was close to 0 at 12 years of age. Our results are consistent with the findings of several previous European studies on physical development in patients with PKU [22-24]. In marked contrast to our findings, a Spanish study has observed normal developmental outcomes in PAH-deficient patients over an observation period from 0 to 18 years of age; even in the most severe phenotypes, who usually are on a strictest diet .
No significant variation was observed in the evolution of BMI Z-scores in the male PKU group, its mean value was close to the 50th percentile for healthy subjects over the observation period. However, the female PKU group showed an increase in the mean Z-score for BMI at 8 years of age (0.98 ± 0.93); and, in contrast to the male group, BMI Z-score was well above 0 at 18 years of age. Mean Z-scores for BMI in the mild-HPA group were approximately 0 from 6 months to 12 years of age, in both the male and female groups. Finally, mean Z-scores for GR in the PKU group showed a gradual decrease between 1.5 and 4.5 years of age, and a sharp fall around puberty in both sub-groups. In the mild-HPA group, mean Z-scores for GR fell steadily in early stages of growth, and remained above the 50th percentile for healthy subjects until 11 years of age, dropping below this threshold from this age onwards.
We also performed paired-sample t-tests, in order to analyse intra-group (male vs. female) and inter-group (male/female- PKU vs. male/female-mild-HPA) differences in anthropometric characteristics. Statistically significant differences in mean Z-scores for height and GR (PKU group: male vs. female) were observed using the Student’s t-test (p < 0.05). In the mild-HPA group, we found significant differences in BMI Z-scores between male and female patients (p < 0.05).
As we expected, mean blood Phe levels were significantly higher in the PKU group than in the mild-HPA group. However, no significant differences were observed in blood Phe levels between the male and female groups.
The intake of nutrients was analysed by age (0-2; 2-9; 9-12 and 12-18 years of age) (Table 1). The statistical analysis indicated that median intakes of natural protein, protein contained in amino acid mixtures and total protein met the recommendations in the Spanish protocol for treating PKU in each group of age [19,20]. However, natural protein intake was below the recommended average value of the World Health Organisation (WHO) for healthy individuals (0-18 years of age); whereas the intakes of the other dietary components containing protein were above the guidelines for normal growth . With regard to Phe intake, its median met the recommendations in the Spanish protocol for treating PKU in each group, but was lower than the guidelines of the WHO.
|Age (years)||Natural protein (g/kg/day)||Protein in amino acid mixtures (g/kg/day)||Total protein (g/kg/day)||Phe (mg/kg/day)|
Table 1: Dietary parameters (intakes of natural protein, protein contained in amino acid mixtures, total protein and Phe) in the PKU group. Values are expressed as median (interquartile range).
In addition, we further evaluated the influence of the Pherestricted diet on physical growth in patients with PKU using bivariate correlation analysis. There was no association between higher protein intakes and attaining improved developmental outcomes in the PKU group. On the other hand, we observed a significant positive correlation between higher Phe intakes and achieving better height Z-scores in the PKU female group (Pearson’s correlation coefficients (r)= 0.76, 0.56 and 0.69, p < 0.05, at 1.5, 2.5 and 4.5 years of age, respectively) as well as in the PKU male group (r= 0.61, 0.73, 0.78, 0.74, 0.86, 0.72 and 0.83, p< 0.05, at 2.5, 3.5, 4.0, 4.5, 5.0, 5.5 and 11 years of age respectively). In addition, weight Z-scores positively correlated with Phe intake in the PKU female group (r= 0.52 and 0.46, p< 0.05, at 1.5 and 2.5 years of age, respectively) and in the PKU male group (r= 0.68, 0.61, 0.74 and 0.78, p< 0.05, at 3.5, 4.0, 4.5 and 5.0 years of age, respectively).
In summary, our findings showed growth impairment in the group of patients with PKU. In particular, there were two welldifferentiated periods of age (from birth to 2 years of age, and from end of growth to adulthood) when height Z-score fell well below 0. We also found a significant positive correlation between height and Phe intake, as well as between weight and Phe intake. On the contrary, in patients with mild-HPA, no growth retardation was observed.
Impact of phenylketonuria on growth in BH4-treated and Phe-restricted dietonly patients
Diet-only patients were on Phe-restricted diets, supplemented with Phe-free amino acid mixtures and specially manufactured low-protein foods (further details are described in the subsection Study 1). With regard to BH4 patients, in an attempt to enable them to consume a normal diet, they gradually increased their intake of certain protein-rich foods, while maintaining BH4 treatment, and consequently they reduced their intake of protein in amino acid mixtures. Although patients with a Phe reduction below 50% in the BH4 loading test could not adopt a normal diet, they obtained at least 70 % of total protein from natural sources. Dietary parameters (such as intakes of natural protein, protein contained in amino acid mixtures, total protein and Phe) for both groups were calculated as described above.
Follow-up data from patients with PKU were collected every 6 months over a period of 2 years. The group on BH4 treatment included 36 patients (18 males and 18 females): 5 with classic PKU, 24 with moderate PKU and 7 with mild PKU. This BH4 group represented the 33 % of total patients with PKU included in this study 2A. The rest of the cohort (72 patients (36 males and 36 females)) was on exclusively Phe-restricted diet supplemented with amino acids. There were 10 patients with classic PKU, 48 with moderate PKU and 14 with mild PKU. Thus, there were two diet-only patients for each BH4 patient matched for age and type of PKU. Overall, there were 54 females and 54 males with an initial age range from 6 months to 15 years.
The comparison of anthropometric characteristics between the BH4 and the diet-only group is shown in Table 2. The negative values of weight and height Z-scores in both groups, which were below the Spanish healthy population, may reflect the impact of a Phe-restricted diet until BH4 treatment was initiated in one of the groups. When we compared both groups, there were no significant differences in the mean Z-scores for height over the observation period. With regard to weight, we observed significant differences (p < 0.05); while Z-scores were higher in the BH4 group comparing with the diet-only group at 6 and 12 months; the mean Z-score for weight was higher in the diet-only group than the BH4 group at 18 and 24 months. BMI Z-scores were significantly higher in the BH4 group than the diet-only group within the two-year follow-up period (p < 0.05). However, this seems not to be related with treatment, since such difference was already significant before treatment was initiated. Consistent with the lack of significant difference in height Z-scores between groups, there was no significant difference in mean Z-scores for GR between them. However, we observed a trend towards decreased GR in the diet-only group comparing with the BH4 group. Moreover, we analysed individually each treatment; there was no significant difference (p > 0.05) between initial and final values in the mean Z-scores for weight, height, BMI or GR, which indicated that the treatment had no substantial effect on those parameters.
|Weight Z-score||Height Z-score||BMI Z-score||GR Z-score|
|Initial||-0.16 ± 1.03||-0.55 ± 0.83||-0.71 ± 1.25||-0.76 ± 1.03||0.31 ± 1.03*||-0.17 ± 0.88*||0.15 ± 2.18||0.02 ± 2.37|
|6 months||-0.08 ± 0.99*||-0.56 ± 0.89*||-0.62 ± 1.13||-0.74 ± 0.99||0.28 ± 0.82*||-0.19 ± 0.96*||0.61 ± 2.15||-0.01 ± 1.23|
|12 moths||-0.13 ± 1.13*||-0.71 ± 0.7*||-0.69 ± 1.1||-0.91 ± 0.88||0.33 ± 1.21*||-0.27 ± 0.77*||0.08 ± 1.67||0.35 ± 1.59|
|18 moths||-0.79 ± 1.17||-0.46 ± 0.9||-0.72 ± 1.12||-0.81 ± 0.98||0.51 ± 1.22*||-0.14 ± 0.87*||-0.01 ± 1.52||0.09 ± 1.73|
|Final||-0.75 ± 1.04*||-0.52 ± 0.85*||-0.73 ± 0.96||-0.90 ± 1.00||0.37 ± 1.09*||-0.12 ± 0.89*||0.05 ± 2.71||0.10 ± 2.26|
Table 2: Anthropometric characteristics (weight, height, BMI and GR Z-scores) in the BH4-treated group comparing with the diet-only group over the two-year follow-up period. Values are expressed as mean ± standard deviation (SD).
With regard to blood Phe levels, mean values were lower in BH4-treated patients than in the low-Phe diet group. There were significant differences between both groups at initial levels (255.2 ± 146.8 mol Phe/L and 418.4 ± 339.6 mol Phe/L, BH4 and dietonly group, respectively; p= 0.003) and between initial and final mean values in the BH4 group (initial: 255.2 ± 146.8 mol Phe/L and final: 365.5 ± 226.5 mol Phe/L; p= 0.005). Furthermore, BH4 administration led to a decrease in the variability of mean blood Phe levels. It should be highlighted that stabilising blood Phe levels in patients with PKU is crucial to prevent neurocognitive impairment, especially during the first years of life. In this regard, it was described that blood Phe values above pre-established “safe” thresholds and its high variability correlated with neurocognitive impairment and psychosocial dysfunction [2,3].
With regard to Phe tolerance over the two-year follow-up, we observed that it increased in 28 of the BH4-treated patients and remained steady in the other 8. Within the group in which Phe tolerance increased, 11 patients gradually managed to adopt a non-restricted diet; while Phe tolerance increased by 329.2 ± 230.2 mg Phe/day in the other 17 patients, who remained on the restricted diet. Daily intake of natural protein slightly increased from prior to initiating BH4 treatment to when patients had been taken the drug for 2 years (Table 3).
|two-year follow-up||five-year follow-up|
|BH4 group||Diet-only group||BH4 group||Diet-only group|
|Phe intake (initial) (mg/kg/day)||29.9
|Phe intake (final) (mg/kg/day)||41.2
|Natural protein intake (initial) (g/kg/day)||0.7
|Natural protein intake (final) (g/kg/day)||0.8
|Protein in amino acid mixtures (initial) (g/kg/day)||0.9
|Protein in amino acid mixtures (final) (g/kg/day)||0.5
|Total protein (initial) (g/kg/day)||1.8
|Total protein (final) (g/kg/day)||1.5
Table 3: Dietary parameters (intakes of natural protein, total protein, protein contained in amino acid mixtures and Phe) in PKU patients on BH4 treatment and on a Phe-restricted diet. Data from the two-year and five-year follow-up studies are included. Values are expressed as median (interquartile range).
Follow-up data from patients with PKU were collected every 6 months over a period of 5 years. The BH4 group included 10 patients (9 with moderate PKU and 1 with mild PKU). The rest of the cohort (20 patients: 12 males and 8 females) was on Phe-restricted diet: 18 with moderate PKU and 2 with mild PKU. Thus, there were two dietonly patients for each BH4 patient, matched for age and type of PKU. The final mean age for the BH4-treated group was 10.2 ± 3.1 years, and for the diet-only group was 10.2 ± 3.0 years.
The comparison of anthropometric characteristics between the BH4- treated and the diet-only group is shown in Table 4. As in the twoyear follow-up period, mean Z-scores for height in both groups were below the average for healthy population. Although mean Z-scores for weight in the BH4 group were also higher than in the diet-only group, the difference did not reach statistical significance (p > 0.05). Furthermore, there was no statistically significant difference between initial and final mean values within each group for mean Z-scores for weight, height, BMI and GR.
|Weight Z-score||Height Z-score||BMI Z-score||GR Z-score|
|Initial||-0.08 ± 1.08||-0.01 ± 1.12||-0.29 ± 1.31||-0.27 ± 1.20||0.23 ± 1.10||0.42 ± 1.02||1.62±1.62||0.78±1.78|
|6 months||0.21 ± 1.13||-0.05 ± 0.99||-0.42 ± 1.17||-0.49 ± 1.26||0.07 ± 0.64||0.17 ± 0.79||-1.31±2.06||0.08±1.31|
|12 months||0.2 ± 1.52||0.07 ± 1.2||-0.29 ± 1.31||-0.44 ± 1.14||0.40 ± 1.49||0.37 ± 1.10||-0.9 ± 1.75||0.03 ± 1.16|
|18 months||0.17 ± 1.45||-0.27 ± 0.98||-0.26 ± 1.13||-0.57 ± 1.06||0.67 ± 1.25||-0.04 ± 0.78||0.60 ± 0.90||-0.00 ± 1.31|
|24 months||0.01 ± 1.26||-0.31 ± 0.82||-0.41 ± 1.26||-0.69 ± 0.95||0.20 ± 1.13||-0.01 ± 0.74||-0.65 ± 1.47||-0.60 ± 0.91|
|30 months||-0.01 ± 1.02||-0.26 ± 0.92||-0.36 ± 0.94||-0.63 ± 1.07||0.18 ± 0.92||0.02 ± 0.73||-1.23 ± 1.07||-0.14 ± 2.17|
|36 months||-0.18 ± 1.03||-0.24 ± 0.93||-0.70 ± 1.23||-0.68 ± 1.01||-0.21 ± 0.53||-0.08 ± 0.82||-0.50 ± 1.57||0.12 ± 0.94|
|42 months||-0.01 ± 1.15||-0.19 ± 0.95||-0.48 ± 1.06||-0.59 ± 1.09||0.29 ± 1.03||0.09 ± 0.80||-0.50 ± 2.41||-0.44 ± 1.53|
|48 months||-0.49 ± 0.94||-0.31 ± 0.87||-0.86 ± 1.01||-0.82 ± 0.87||-0.09 ± 0.72||0.11 ± 1.01||-0.45 ± 1.84||-0.46 ± 1.20|
|54 months||0.05 ± 1.29||-0.23 ± 0.92||-0.58 ± 1.06||-0.62 ± 1.12||0.31 ± 1.19||0.02 ± 0.85||0.31 ± 2.27||-0.09 ± 1.47|
|Final||-0.10 ± 1.01||-0.18 ± 0.88||-0.52 ± 0.90||-0.56 ± 1.09||0.12 ± 1.03||0.04 ± 0.80||0.41 ± 1.67||0.34 ± 2.10|
Table 4: Anthropometric characteristics (weight, height, BMI and GR Z-scores) in the BH4-treated group comparing with the diet-only group over the five-year follow-up period. Values are expressed as mean ± standard deviation (SD).
With regard to blood Phe levels, mean values were slightly higher in the diet-only group comparing with the BH4-treated group, but this difference did not reach statistical significance at any time point (p > 0.05). In addition, there was no statistically significant difference between initial and final mean blood Phe levels in either group (BH4 group, initial: 204.2 ± 143.9 and final: 289.6 ± 30.6 mol Phe/L; and diet-only group, initial: 391.8 ± 233.5 and final: 440.6 ± 298.4 mol Phe/L).
In the five-year follow-up study, we observed that Phe tolerance increased in 6 patients, whereas it remained steady in 2 patients. This level of tolerance did not fall below baseline value in any patient. Within the group in which Phe tolerance increased, 2 patients gradually managed to adopt a non-restricted diet; while Phe tolerance increased by 648.7 ± 348.0 mg Phe/day in the other patients, who required a restricted diet. Daily intake of natural protein slightly increased in the BH4 group at the end of the five-year follow-up, and it was three times higher than in the diet-only group (Table 3).
In summary, our findings showed that there was no improvement in the anthropometric variables in the cohort on BH4 treatment, from prior to initiating the treatment to when they had taken the drug for 2 or 5 years. Hence, in almost all cases there was a fall in the mean Z-score for the anthropometric variables during these periods, although the differences did not reach statistical significance. In addition, growth impairment was noted in patients on low-Phe diets. Furthermore, we found no statistically significant differences between both groups at any time point. It should be noted that individuals on BH4 treatment increased their natural protein intake and, in some cases, this allowed them to consume normal diets with protein intake meeting the RDAs. However, no association was observed between higher protein intake and growth.
Dietary intervention is one of the currently available treatments options for PKU. This approach, which consists of a marked reduction in Phe intake, has shown to prevent severe neurological impairment which was observed in untreated patients. However, while several reports indicated that an excessive reduction in Phe intake resulted in poor developmental outcomes in patients with PKU; others have not found evidence of the PKU diet negatively affecting physical development. Considering the importance of attaining optimal growth in patients with PKU, we conducted a retrospective longitudinal study on the developmental outcomes in a Spanish cohort of PAH-deficient patients (PKU and mild- HPA) who were exclusively treated with protein-restricted diets. The main conclusion from this study was that patients with PKU showed growth impairment in early stages; whereas physical growth was not impaired in patients with mild-HPA. Since BMI remained relatively steady and close to Z-score=0 from birth to 18 years of age; malnutrition can be ruled out as the leading cause of growth impairment in our patients with PKU. Higher protein intakes have been suggested to be related to improved developmental outcomes, although it has not yet been defined which protein fraction (natural protein, protein substitutes or the combination of both [total protein]) exerts the most influence on physical development. In our cohort, we observed that higher Phe intake in the PKU group was associated with attaining improved developmental outcomes in early stages. Therefore, we suggest that prescribing very stringent diets during this period (first 4 years of life) might predispose patients with PKU to later growth retardation, with growth outcomes in adulthood being well below the 50th percentile for healthy subjects. Moreover, it may be possible that insufficient intake of other nutrients, such as sources of energy or trace elements (selenium or zinc), underlie growth impairment in the PKU population, as it has been previously proposed . Unfortunately, no data on these nutrients were available in our study. However, since patients with PKU on glycomacropeptide-diet and patients with mild- HPA seem to have better growth outcomes than patients on a protein-restricted diet, we hypothesize that the most likely cause of growth impairment is the low protein intake. We consider that amino acids in the supplements may be less efficient than natural amino acids, because of faster oxidation and differences in their metabolism. Further research would be required to elucidate the mechanisms that underlie growth impairment in the PKU population, to confirm the association between reduced protein intakes and poorer growth outcomes. In addition, it would be interesting to evaluate epigenetics and creatine deficit and their relationship with growth outcomes in PKU.
Over the last decade, BH4 therapy has been extensively used to treat PAH-deficient patients who respond to a BH4 loading test. This treatment has improved the management of these patients [28,29]. However, very few studies have explored growth outcomes in patients on BH4 treatment. Among them, Singh et al. reported that height Z-score increased significantly after 2 years on BH4 treatment . In addition, they observed that natural protein became the main protein source in the diet, although amino acid supplementation was not always discontinued. Hence, our study aimed to assess to what extent growth in patients with PKU was influenced by BH4 administration, since it allows them to consume larger amounts of natural proteins. The main conclusion was that BH4-treated patients displayed growth impairment, despite the fact that their natural protein intake increased. Moreover, individuals on long-term BH4 treatment seemed to achieve similar developmental outcomes to those on more restricted diets. In fact, mean Z-score for almost all anthropometric variables in both groups fell to the same extent, reaching similar final values. It should be noted that we also observed growth impairment in patients on proteinrestricted diets, which is consistent with previous reports [22,23,27,30-31]. However, in contrast to previous studies, increasing natural protein intake did not seem to have a positive effect on developmental outcomes. In fact, both types of diets seemed to lead patients with PKU to physical development impairment, attaining similar growth outcomes at the end of the observation period. As abovementioned, we concluded that prescribing very stringent diets during the first years of life might lead to growth retardation in PKU. Moreover, our findings suggested that BH4 therapy, along with the subsequent increase in natural protein intake in these patients, might not counteract the negative impact of the deprived diet during the period prior to initiating BH4 treatment.
One of BH4 therapy’s aims is to enable patients with PKU to consume normal diets and free them from the need to take Phefree substitutes. It should be mentioned that many patients on BH4 treatment in our cohort did not manage to liberalise their diet at the end of the observation period. Moreover, no increase in Phe intake was observed in some BH4 patients in either twoyear or five-year follow-ups. Taking into account these findings, the question arises as to whether the current protocols to assess BH4 responsiveness, in particular the 30 % criterion, lead to the detection of true responders to the cofactor-based treatment. In our opinion, a shift towards a stricter criterion for responsiveness might ensure that responders to BH4 treatment would not withdraw from this treatment at later stages. In fact, a new protocol for assessing BH4 responsiveness based on a 50 % criterion has been recently published . Analysis of the protocol showed that, with this criterion, all responders to the BH4 loading test were true responders to long-term BH4 treatment, and all these patients consumed normal diets with no need to take amino acid supplements.
To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that anthropometric characteristics have been assessed in such a large cohort of patients with PKU on BH4 treatment and over longer observation period (five- vs. two-year follow-up) comparing with previously published studies. Nevertheless, we consider that further research would be necessary in order to explore in more detail how BH4 treatment affects the health status of patients with PKU.
We thank all patients for kindly participating in the study. This work was supported in part by NUTRICIA S.L.R. (Madrid, Spain).
The study protocol was approved by Clinical Research Ethics Committees at each hospital involved in this study. Written informed consent was obtained from patients and parents or legal guardians of all the children included.